IMPROVING EXECUTIVE – LEGISLATIVE RELATIONSHIP IN NIGERIA DEMOCRATIC GOVERNANCE: CHALLENGES AND REMEDIES
Abstract
This study critically interrogated the root causes, challenges and remedies for Executive – Legislative conflicts in democratic governance in Nigeria. The study relied heavily on secondary data from in-depth desk review of books, journals, magazines, government documents, internet publications, newspapers etc. Also, the study made use of primary data from interview of key stakeholders in Nigeria Politics such as: the executive, the legislature, the judiciary, leaders of political parties and pro-democracy Organizations. The essence of the interview is to complement and authenticate some of the views previously expressed by the key stakeholders which were documented in the various sources of the secondary data utilized for this study collected from the field work. Since the data collected for the study is qualitative in nature, content analysis was adopted as the method for data analyses. Also, the Role conflict theory was adopted as the theoretical frame work of analysis which equally guided the study in the collection of relevant data and formulation of the interview questions for the political stakeholders in Nigerian Politics. The result of the findings from the content analysis of the secondary and primary data collected reveal the following areas as the major sources of conflicts in the executive – legislative relationship in the democratic governance in Nigeria namely: Violations of Constitutional provisions by the executive and legislature; Lack of respect for the rule of law and the principles of separation of powers; Management of Public funds especially in the area of the screening and approval of Budget; Performance of oversight functions; performance of Law making function by the legislature such as the passage of the Electoral Act bill 2018 and the Veto by the President; Appointment and ratification of key government functionaries such as the refusal of the legislature to confirm Mr. Magu, the former Economic and Financial Crime Commission (EFCC), boss in 2016 and 2017 respectively etc. Based on the main findings of the study, the following Major recommendations were made as remedies and panacea for improving the executive – legislative relationship in the democratic governance in Nigeria viz:- Both organs of governance should respect the rule of law/separation of powers and consult regularly in the area of disagreement; Both organs should see the supremacy of constitution as uppermost in the discharge of their respective roles, and appreciate that the essence of constitutional provisions is to ensure good governance through their independent and co-operative roles; open up effective communication channels for uninterrupted information flow to promote mutual understanding and cooperation between the two organs; Dialogue and regular meetings by both organs of governance should be institutionalized and Financial autonomy for the legislature.
Keywords
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Abatan, O. (2005) “Alamieyesigha Impeached”, The Sunday Independent, December, 11.
Abayemi, T.(2002). “Much Ado About Appropriation Act”, The Guardian, June, 25.
Aberbach, D. & Rockman, (1992). Improving Executive-Legislative Relations in the Making and Implementation of policy. Los Angel: Center for America Politics and Public Policy, University of California.
Adamolekun, L. (2008). “Executive-legislative Relations, since 1999”, The Vanguard, January, 30.
Adisa, T. (2007), “Agenda for Yar’ Adua Presidency: Improving on Executive/Legislative Relations”, The Nigerian Tribune, May, 31.
Adisa, T. (2007), “The Obasanjo Years: Executive Meddling and Legislative Resistance”, the Nigeria Tribune, May, 18.
Adisa, T. (2008). “Impeachment; Bankole Must-go-Rep. divide over money”, the Tribune, June, 24.
Agena, T. (2013). “Executive-legislative conflict in Nigeria’s Democracy since 1999 in studies on Nigerian Legislature” 1999-2011 (eds) Ukase, P; Afaha, P & Larab, T: vast publisher, Ibadan-Nigeria.
Aguda, O. (2008) “The Legislators oversight function”, The Nation, June, 5.
Airhuobhor, A. (2007) “Dariye return” The Newswatch, May, 19.
Ajaero, C. (2006). “Man of the Year, Ken Nnamani”, The Newswatch, January, 15.
Amadi, E.O (2005). “Fundamentals of Executive-Legislature Relation”, Enugu: Zik-Chuks Publisher.
Aminu, J. (2006). “Improving Executive/Legislature Relation” The Newswatch, June, 19.
Amucheazi, E. & Ibeanu, O. (2008) “Between the theory and practice of democracy in Nigeria”. An Assessment of Obasanjo’s first term in office by Academics and Practitioners, London Adonis & Abbey Publishers Ltd.
Andewag, R (1992), “Executive-legislative relation in Netherland; consecutive and coexisting patterns” The Legislative Studies Quarterly Vol. XV11, No.2
Andor, O. (2005) “National Assembly Blamed for Poor Budget Implementation”, The Thisday, December, 20.
Anne, C. (1988). “Montesquieus’ Comparative Politics and the Spirit of American Constitutionalism” Lawrence: University Press of Kenes.
Antonio, J. (2007). Presidentialism, Parliamentarism and Democracy; Cambridge; Cambridge University Press.
Barnabas, R. (2019) “Effect of Executive-legislature conflicts on governance in Nigeria (1999-2017)”. Unpublished Doctoral Thesis Department of Public Administration, Kogi State University, Anyigba.
Biddle, B.I. (1986), “Recent development in role theory” The Annual Review of Sociology Vol.1, No.12
Blatner, A. (2006). “Role Dynamics; An Integrative Approach to Psychology and User- Friendly Language” Accessed at
Davies, A. (1995) “Executive-Legislative Relations and Democratization during the Transition Programme” Paper presented at the conference on Democratization and corruption in Nigeria, held at University of Ibadan
Edward, I. Barret, G & Peake, J. (1977), “The Legislative Impact of Divide Government”, American Journal of Political Science, 543-563
Eme, O. (2016) “Executive-Legislative Relations in Era of Accelerated Reform: Reshaping Government in Nigeria”, the Legislative Studies Quarterly, vol. xxxiv, No.3
Ezirirm, G. (2017) “Executive-legislature Relations as a Recouped for democratic Dividend”, text of Lecture delivered at the Annual Public Lecture organizes by the Faculty of Social Science of the University of Nigeria, Nsukka.
Fawole, W. (2013) “Executive-Legislative Relationship” in A.S Obyen & K. Amuwo (eds), Nigeria’s Democratic Experience in the Fourth Republic Since 1999 Policies and Politics. Lanharm, London, New-york; University Press American Inc. Federal Republic of Nigeria (1999), the Constitution of Federal Republic of Nigeria Abuja; Federal Ministry of Information.
Gana, J. (2008). “The Imperative of Harmonious Legislative/Executive Relationship in the Sustenance of an enduring Democracy”. The Daily Independent, April, 23.
Nwankwo, B. & Barnabas, R (2019) Field Work Analysis on “Effect of Executive-Legislative Conflicts on Governance in Nigeria” (1999-2017), Doctoral Thesis submitted to the Department of Public Administration, Kogi State University, Anyigba.
Nwankwo, B. (2019) “Elections and Democratic Governability in Nigeria”, the Journal of International Politics and Development Studies vol. 14 No.3
Nwankwo, B. (2020) Field Work Content Analysis on “Improving Executive-Legislative relationship in Nigeria democratic Governance; Challenges and Remedies”, Unpublished.
Nwaogu, N. (2013). “Executive-Legislative Relations and Challenges of National Security”, text of a lecture delivered at the Annual public lecture organize by the Faculty of Social Science, University of Nigeria, Nsukka.
Nwosu, S. (2007) “Executive Power and Presidential Democracy Issues and Lessons”, the Journal of International Politics and Development Studies vol.3, No.1 July/December.
Ogdoma, F. (2012) “The Theory of Separation of Powers in Nigeria; an Assessment”, African Research Review vol. 6(3) Multi Disciplinary Journal.
Okpeh, O. (2014), Forward on a History of Executive-Legislative Relations in Nigeria, 1914-2007, written by Ukase, P. Ibadan University Press.
Ukase, P. (2014) “A History of Executive-Legislative Relations in Nigeria”, 1914-2007, Ibadan University Press.
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
Copyright (c) 2021 Prof. Basil Chukwuemeka Nwankwo (PhD), Barnabas Rosemary Nneoma (PhD)
ISSN (PRINT): 2682 - 6135
ISSN (ONLINE): 2682 - 6127
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.